55 Rutland Road

PLG GEM

A rare opportunity to rent one of Prospect Lefferts Gardens' most distinguished landmark residences, this meticulously restored circa-1897 limestone townhouse seamlessly blends historic grandeur with contemporary luxury. Designed by acclaimed architect John J. Petit, this four-story single-family masterpiece has been thoughtfully reimagined for modern living while preserving the exceptional craftsmanship and architectural integrity that define Brooklyn's finest historic homes.

The expansive garden level serves as the heart of the home, offering an exceptional open-concept layout ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Anchored by one of six original decorative fireplaces found throughout the home, the living area flows effortlessly into a gracious dining space with custom built-ins and a chef-caliber kitchen featuring a six-burner Wolf range, a second built-in conventional oven, a professional microwave, Sub-Zero refrigeration, dual Bosch dishwashers, and an oversized statuary marble island. Floor-to-ceiling glass doors open to a beautifully landscaped private garden complete with outdoor kitchen, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle rarely found in Brooklyn.

The formal parlor level showcases an extraordinary collection of original details bathed in natural light from south-facing windows and leaded glass accents. Elegant pier mirrors, soaring ceilings, intricate millwork, and a dramatic coffered music room create a sense of timeless sophistication. The formal dining room and library, inspired by the renowned Moorish Room at the Brooklyn Museum and the Morgan Library, offers a truly one-of-a-kind setting for entertaining and quiet reflection alike.

Occupying the upper floors are five generously proportioned bedrooms, including a serene primary suite spanning the full width of the home. The suite features a sitting area, custom fireplace adorned with hand-painted Italian tile, dual walk-in closets, and a spa-quality marble bath with steam shower. Additional bedrooms are complemented by beautifully appointed marble baths and a substantial laundry room. The third floor hallway is crowned by a stunning original stained glass skylight, one of the home's most beloved architectural details.

Modern amenities include zoned central air conditioning, radiant heated bathroom floors, CAT-6 wiring throughout, integrated security system, climate-controlled wine cellar, additional refrigerator, and a full basement offering extensive storage and utility space.

Location & Transportation

Situated within the historic Lefferts Manor Historic District, the home offers exceptional connectivity to the best of Brooklyn. Prospect Park, multiple playgrounds, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, the Prospect Park Carousel, and the Brooklyn Zoo are all within easy walking distance, making this an especially appealing address for families. The B, Q, and 2/5 subway lines provide fast, convenient access to Manhattan and beyond.

The neighborhood is home to several highly regarded schools within walking distance, including Lefferts Gardens Montessori School, Maple Street School, and The Almond Tree Group of Schools. Families seeking independent, charter, and specialized programs will also find convenient bus access from the neighborhood to Brooklyn Friends School, Prospect Schools, Berkeley Carroll School, Brooklyn Prospect Charter School, Brooklyn New School, and The NEST School, among many others -- with both public school transportation and private school bus stops serving the area.

Pets considered on a case-by-case basis.