Water Mill, NY
Explore our neighborhoods

Water Mill, NY

Water Mill, NY blends historic charm with modern luxury, offering a mix of farmland, waterfront beauty, and elegant estates. Originally powered by a colonial-era gristmill, the hamlet still reflects its rural roots with scenic open fields, horse farms, and quiet roads perfect for biking. The real estate includes grand homes with water views, secluded compounds, and stylish new builds. Art and culture thrive here, with galleries and seasonal events enriching the experience. Water Mill’s location between Southampton and Bridgehampton gives residents easy access to high-end dining, shopping, and beaches, while still maintaining a more relaxed, private atmosphere. Mecox Bay, with its calm waters and kayaking opportunities, adds to the area’s natural appeal. Whether enjoying the beach, catching a sunset over the fields, or attending a local farm stand or exhibition, Water Mill offers a harmonious balance of countryside calm and coastal sophistication. It’s a sought-after destination for refined, peaceful Hamptons living.

show more
Water Mill, NY

Highlights

  • $100K - 26M Price Range
  • $4.52M Avg. Sold Price
  • $5.94M Avg. List Price
  • $1,518 Avg. Price per Sqft
  • 57 Homes for Sale
  • 72 Homes for Rent
View Gallery VIEW PHOTO GALLERY
Water Mill, NY

Recent Listings

Water Mill, NY

Neighborhood Lifestyle

Bikeable

The Hamptons are popular for biking, especially in warmer months. Scenic roads, flat terrain, and charming village centers make cycling enjoyable and accessible. Many towns have bike lanes or low-traffic routes ideal for leisure rides. Cyclists often explore beaches, farms, and historic sites by bike. Designated trails and peaceful backroads offer a great way to experience the area’s natural beauty and coastal charm on two wheels.

Historic

The Hamptons have deep colonial roots, with settlements dating back to the 1600s. Historic homes, churches, and museums preserve the area’s rich heritage. Whaling, farming, and fishing played key roles in shaping early life. In the late 19th century, the region evolved into a summer escape for New Yorkers. Today, the blend of preserved history and upscale living offers a unique glimpse into centuries of coastal culture and transformation.

Waterfront

The Hamptons are known for their stunning waterfronts, featuring ocean beaches, bays, and harbors. Pristine stretches like Coopers Beach and Main Beach draw sunseekers, while calmer bay areas are perfect for boating, paddleboarding, and kayaking. Waterfront homes offer scenic views and private access. The coastline shapes the area’s lifestyle, with beach clubs, marinas, and seaside dining all adding to the region’s coastal charm and appeal.

  • Water Mill is accessible by car via Montauk Highway and offers a Long Island Rail Road stop for direct travel to and from New York City. The Hampton Jitney also serves the area, providing convenient coach service. Most residents rely on cars to get around, though biking is common for local trips. Nearby regional airports offer chartered flights for those seeking fast travel to and from the Hamptons.

  • Water Mill is named after its historic water-powered gristmill, one of the oldest in the U.S. The area also features cultural landmarks like art galleries and historic homes, blending heritage with creativity. The nearby Parrish Art Museum, while just outside the hamlet, adds to the cultural experience with exhibits and events that reflect the region’s artistic influence.

  • Real estate in Water Mill features sprawling estates, modern farmhouses, and waterfront homes. Many properties are large, private, and professionally landscaped, offering both rural charm and high-end finishes. From historic cottages to cutting-edge architecture, homes here appeal to those seeking luxury in a serene, countryside-meets-coastal setting.

  • Life in Water Mill moves at a relaxed pace, rooted in privacy, elegance, and connection to nature. Residents enjoy a refined, low-key atmosphere with access to the arts, outdoor recreation, and nearby Hamptons hotspots. It's a community that values space, peace, and a balanced blend of rural simplicity and modern sophistication.

  • Dining in Water Mill includes upscale restaurants, quaint cafes, and nearby farm stands offering fresh, local ingredients. The culinary scene emphasizes seasonal produce, seafood, and a mix of contemporary and classic dishes. Whether it’s brunch on a sunny patio or dinner at a stylish bistro, the options are refined yet approachable.

  • Water Mill’s nightlife is understated, focusing on elegant evenings and private gatherings. Some restaurants offer wine bars or live music, and the scene is generally calm and sophisticated. Residents often enjoy quiet nights under the stars, local art events, or short drives to nearby villages for more vibrant entertainment.

  • Shopping in Water Mill is boutique-focused and laid-back, with curated shops offering home goods, fashion, and locally made items. While the hamlet itself is quiet, nearby towns like Bridgehampton and Southampton offer a broader range of retail, from high-end designers to artisanal markets and charming local finds.

  • The outdoors in Water Mill are defined by expansive fields, peaceful bayfront views, and quiet beaches. Mecox Bay offers kayaking and paddleboarding, while nearby beaches are ideal for sunbathing or coastal walks. Trails, farms, and open space provide a tranquil backdrop for enjoying nature in all seasons.

Water Mill, NY

Neighborhood Stories

Best beach in the Hamptons - Flying Point Beach - great views everywhere of bays, oceans and farm fields

Richard Finder

Located between Southampton and Bridgehampton this special area is surrounded by farm fields

Robert Nelson
Water Mill, NY

Location

Water Mill, NY

Contributors

Robert Nelson Executive Managing Director, Hamptons
Richard Finder Licensed Real Estate Salesperson