Sag Harbor, NY
Explore our neighborhoods

Sag Harbor, NY

View ALL Listings

Sag Harbor is a charming waterfront village with a rich maritime history and a vibrant cultural scene. Once a bustling whaling port, it still retains its historic charm with preserved 18th- and 19th-century architecture, quaint streets, and iconic landmarks like the Custom House and Old Whaler’s Church. The village offers a unique blend of sophistication and laid-back appeal, with boutique shops, art galleries, and renowned dining spots lining Main Street. The Bay Street Theater brings year-round entertainment, while the marina buzzes with boating activity in warmer months. Residents and visitors enjoy waterfront parks, sailing, kayaking, and peaceful sunsets over Sag Harbor Bay. Real estate ranges from historic homes to stylish modern retreats. With its inclusive, creative vibe and walkable layout, Sag Harbor appeals to artists, families, and those seeking a welcoming yet elevated coastal lifestyle.

show more
Sag Harbor, NY

Highlights

  • $359K - 18M Price Range
  • $2.42M Avg. Sold Price
  • $3.60M Avg. List Price
  • $1,154 Avg. Price per Sqft
  • 66 Homes for Sale
  • 95 Homes for Rent
View Gallery VIEW PHOTO GALLERY
Sag Harbor, NY

Featured Listings

22 Round Pond Lane
22 Round Pond Lane $6,895,000 7 beds, 9.5 baths, 8,500 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
2524 Noyack Road
3D Tour
2524 Noyack Road $6,495,000 7 beds, 9.5 baths, 7,985 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
20 Whalers Walk
Contract Signed
20 Whalers Walk $5,495,000 4 beds, 3.5 baths, 1,850 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
76 Island View Drive West
76 Island View Drive West $2,595,000 4 beds, 4.5 baths, 2,200 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
7 Sims Avenue
New
Contract Signed
7 Sims Avenue $2,395,000 3 beds, 4 baths, 1,800 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
Sag Harbor, NY

Recent Listings

2 B West Water Street
2 B West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY $17,900,000 8 beds, 9 baths, 11726 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
2 "b" W Water Street
2 "b" W Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY $15,500,000 8 beds, 9 baths, 11723 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
22 Round Pond Lane
22 Round Pond Lane, Sag Harbor, NY $6,895,000 7 beds, 9 baths, 8500 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
210 Redwood Road
210 Redwood Road, Sag Harbor, NY $6,500,000 3 beds, 2 baths, 1700 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
2524 Noyack Road
2524 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor, NY $6,495,000 7 beds, 9 baths, 7985 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
View All listings 
1 Carver Street
1 Carver Street, Sag Harbor, NY $3,850,000 3 beds, 3 baths, 3000 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
55 Pine Neck Avenue
55 Pine Neck Avenue, Sag Harbor, NY $550,000* 5 beds, 6 baths, 5200 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
32 Glover Street
32 Glover Street, Sag Harbor, NY $400,000* 5 beds, 4 baths, 3400 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
6 Sunset Drive
6 Sunset Drive, Sag Harbor, NY $145,000* 4 beds, 3 baths, 2100 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
51 Dumar Drive
51 Dumar Drive, Sag Harbor, NY $125,000* 4 beds, 3 baths, 2500 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
View All listings 
471 Middle Line Highway
471 Middle Line Highway, Sag Harbor, NY $7,975,000 8 beds, 7 baths, 8000 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
5 Oak Drive
5 Oak Drive, Sag Harbor, NY $1,495,000 2 beds, 1 baths, 648 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
1 Burkeshire Drive
1 Burkeshire Drive, Sag Harbor, NY $50,000/mo 2 beds, 2 baths, 2197 sqft
Sag Harbor, NY
Sag Harbor, NY

Neighborhood Lifestyle

Bikeable

The Hamptons are popular for biking, especially in warmer months. Scenic roads, flat terrain, and charming village centers make cycling enjoyable and accessible. Many towns have bike lanes or low-traffic routes ideal for leisure rides. Cyclists often explore beaches, farms, and historic sites by bike. Designated trails and peaceful backroads offer a great way to experience the area’s natural beauty and coastal charm on two wheels.

Historic

The Hamptons have deep colonial roots, with settlements dating back to the 1600s. Historic homes, churches, and museums preserve the area’s rich heritage. Whaling, farming, and fishing played key roles in shaping early life. In the late 19th century, the region evolved into a summer escape for New Yorkers. Today, the blend of preserved history and upscale living offers a unique glimpse into centuries of coastal culture and transformation.

Waterfront

The Hamptons are known for their stunning waterfronts, featuring ocean beaches, bays, and harbors. Pristine stretches like Coopers Beach and Main Beach draw sunseekers, while calmer bay areas are perfect for boating, paddleboarding, and kayaking. Waterfront homes offer scenic views and private access. The coastline shapes the area’s lifestyle, with beach clubs, marinas, and seaside dining all adding to the region’s coastal charm and appeal.

  • Sag Harbor is accessible via the Hampton Jitney, providing direct service to and from New York City. Local taxi services operate 24/7, offering transportation within the village and to nearby towns. The Long Island Rail Road stations in Bridgehampton and East Hampton are quite nearby. The village's walkable layout and scenic streets make walking and biking popular modes of transportation.

  • Sag Harbor boasts a rich maritime history, evident in landmarks like the Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, which showcases the village's whaling past. The Old Whaler's Church, a prominent 19th-century structure, stands as a testament to the village's architectural heritage. Bay Street Theater serves as a cultural hub, offering performances and events year-round. These landmarks reflect the village's blend of history and culture.

  • The real estate in Sag Harbor features a mix of historic homes and modern residences. Many properties retain their original charm, with restored cottages and Victorian-era houses lining the streets. Waterfront properties offer stunning views of the bay, while newer constructions provide contemporary amenities. The village's real estate market caters to both year-round residents and seasonal visitors seeking a blend of tradition and modernity.

  • Sag Harbor offers a relaxed yet vibrant lifestyle, attracting artists, writers, and families. The village's rich cultural scene, combined with its maritime heritage, creates a unique atmosphere. Residents enjoy community events, art galleries, and outdoor activities. The close-knit community fosters a sense of belonging, while the scenic surroundings provide a tranquil backdrop for daily life.

  • Dining in Sag Harbor emphasizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Restaurants range from casual eateries to upscale establishments, many offering waterfront views. The culinary scene reflects the village's coastal location, with seafood being a staple on many menus. Seasonal dishes highlight the region's produce, providing diners with a taste of the local flavor in both traditional and innovative preparations.

  • Nightlife in Sag Harbor is characterized by its laid-back ambiance. Local bars and lounges offer a cozy setting for evening gatherings, often featuring live music and events. The village's cultural venues, such as Bay Street Theater, host performances that extend into the night. While the nightlife scene is more subdued compared to larger cities, it provides residents and visitors with intimate and enjoyable experiences.

  • Sag Harbor's shopping scene is a blend of boutique stores, art galleries, and specialty shops. Main Street is lined with establishments offering unique clothing, home décor, and artisanal goods. The village's retail offerings reflect its artistic community, with many shops showcasing local craftsmanship. Shoppers can find a mix of contemporary fashion and timeless antiques, catering to diverse tastes.

  • The village offers numerous outdoor activities, from sailing and kayaking in the harbor to relaxing on local beaches like Foster Memorial and Havens Beach. Parks and nature trails provide opportunities for hiking and birdwatching, allowing residents and visitors to connect with nature. The scenic waterfront and green spaces enhance the village's appeal, promoting an active and outdoor-oriented lifestyle.

Sag Harbor, NY

Neighborhood Stories

This historic whaling village today has beautiful renovated homes.

Robert Nelson

Have you ever hiked to the top of the dunes at Barcelona Point to see one of the most beautiful views on the East End? Let me know the next time you are in the Hamptons!

Jane Babcook

Sag Harbor has the best of the Hamptons experiences including boating, nature, history, and some of the best shopping and restaurant options on the East End. Having lived here for over 30 years, I have always loved living here and enjoy showing it off to visitors, as well as potential customers!

Kathleen Mulcahy

I live on Round Pond in Sag Harbor, which is part of the Long Pond Greenbelt area. I enjoy hiking the many trails of the LPG with its amazing places to explore, including its mix of ponds, wetlands, and oak forests.

Kim Kakerbeck

Sag Harbor Village in the off season is a hidden gem. You can experience everything the summer has to offer in a bit more relaxed atmosphere.

Jeanne Galante

Vibrant, historic, and charming Sag Harbor Village may have eclipsed all the other hamlets, as being one of the top year-round destinations in the Hamptons.

Carol Abady
Sag Harbor, NY

Location

Explore Other

The Hamptons Neighborhoods

Sag Harbor, NY

Market News

A Piece of Film History: D.A. Pennebaker’s Sag Harbor Home Finds a New Owner

A Piece of Film History: D.A. Pennebaker’s Sag Harbor Home Finds a New Owner
Hamptons Classic: Four Shingle-Style Homes on the East End

Hamptons Classic: Four Shingle-Style Homes on the East End
Sea You Out There: Six Waterfront Homes with Private Docks

Sea You Out There: Six Waterfront Homes with Private Docks
Local Legends: Celebrating Women-Owned Businesses in the Hamptons

Local Legends: Celebrating Women-Owned Businesses in the Hamptons
The BHS Agent Spotlight on Jane Babcook

The BHS Agent Spotlight on Jane Babcook
Find Your 'Stars Hollow': Dream Homes for 'Gilmore Girls' Fans

Find Your 'Stars Hollow': Dream Homes for 'Gilmore Girls' Fans
Celebrate Halloween in Sag Harbor with Brown Harris Stevens

Celebrate Halloween in Sag Harbor with Brown Harris Stevens
The 'Hearth' of the Home: 7 Homes with Elegant Fireplaces

The 'Hearth' of the Home: 7 Homes with Elegant Fireplaces
Go for the Gold with These Olympic-Worthy Homes on the Market

Go for the Gold with These Olympic-Worthy Homes on the Market
The Joys of Living in the Sag Harbor Village Historic District

The Joys of Living in the Sag Harbor Village Historic District
VIEW ALL MARKET NEWS
Sag Harbor, NY

Similar Neighborhoods

East Hampton
The Hamptons East Hampton  
Montauk
The Hamptons Montauk  
Westhampton Beach
The Hamptons Westhampton Beach  
Sag Harbor, NY

Contributors

Carol G. Abady Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Jeanne Galante Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Kimberly Kakerbeck Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Kathleen Mulcahy Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Robert Nelson Executive Managing Director, Hamptons