44 Saint Marys Road
Shelter Island, NY
$4,495,000 Price
4 Bedrooms  

Shelter Island Subdivide/Work-Residence

This meticulously crafted Shelter Island 8.12 +/- acre estate property is currently configured with 3 substantial structures: a 3 bedroom, 4 bath primary residence, a 2-car carriage house with loft apartment, and a 3-stall horse barn with tack room and loft space. This is a rare opportunity to live...

This meticulously crafted Shelter Island 8.12 +/- acre estate property is currently configured with 3 substantial structures: a 3 bedroom, 4 bath primary residence, a 2-car carriage house with loft apartment, and a 3-stall horse barn with tack room and loft space. This is a rare opportunity to live your equestrian dreams or reimagine this C-Zone property as a sprawling compound with commercial/work options. The property can be subdivided into separate parcels. The pastures, paddocks, and cedar groves make this a true gem for horse enthusiasts, a compound with multiple dwelling options or a gym/yoga, art studio, or light commercial/work spaces. The centerpiece of this remarkable estate is the main residence, a 3,225 +/- af country home featuring 3 ensuite bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. The home also features a formal dining room, entryway, main floor laundry, and ample size living room. Also on the first floor, the primary suite features a beautiful sunroom with radiant heat floors, a large dressing room, and an extra-large ensuite bathroom with a soaking tub. The second floor hosts two ensuite bedrooms and a bonus media/lounge room as an optional 4th bedroom with high ceilings. The finished expansive lower level with a full bath is a walkout to the rolling property. Above the two-car garage, there is a loft space with high ceilings, a balcony overlooking the 18 x 44 gunite pool with a waterfall, a kitchen, and a full bathroom. In addition, the property has a functional horse barn with 3 stalls, a tack room, and loft space. This expansive Shelter Island property represents a rare opportunity to own a world-class equestrian estate in one of the most beautiful and sought-after locations in the region.

Calculate your Payments

Asking Price:

Percent Down:

Loan Amount:

Interest Rate:

Loan Term (years):

Estimated Mortgage Payment:

Monthly Real Estate Tax:

Total Monthly Payment:

* All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental, financing or estimated mortgage rates is from sources deemed reliable but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof. For further financing information, please contact a Brown Harris Stevens agent.

Listing Details

Shelter Island, NY
Type: House
Price: $4,495,000
Approx. sqft: 4,478 sf
Re Tax: $11,186
Last Updated: 4/27/2024
Web ID: 905723

Info & Amenities

Type: Single Family
Size: 8.12 acres
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 5.0
Outdoor space: Patio
Fireplaces: 2
Built: 1985
Central Air: Yes
Garage: Yes
Room for Tennis: Yes
Style: Colonial
Pool: Yes

Map of Area for 44 Saint Marys Road

Listing Agent(s)

Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent David Tenenbaum
David Tenenbaum
Email David
o: 631-771-5322
c: 347-907-5939
Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Timothy C. Burch
Timothy C. Burch
Email Timothy
o: 631-771-5315
c: 917-275-3303

More from these Agents

5 Clyden Road, Wainscott, Hamptons, NY - 3 Bedrooms  
3 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 18
5 Clyden Road
$42,500*
Wainscott
3 BR  |  3 BA
Seasonal Availability*

July Rental: $42,500
August - LD Rental: $50,000

Leslie Hillel  (631) 771-5311
David Tenenbaum  (631) 771-5322
561 Wainscott Northwest Road, Wainscott, Hamptons, NY - 7 Bedrooms  
6.5 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 23
561 Wainscott Northwest Road
$100,000*
Wainscott
7 BR  |  6.5 BA
Seasonal Availability*

January Rental: $20,000
February Rental: $20,000
March Rental: $20,000
April Rental: $30,000
May Rental: $45,000
MD - LD Rental: $250,000
June Rental: $50,000
July Rental: $100,000
August Rental: $100,000
August - LD Rental: $100,000
September Rental: $45,000
October Rental: $20,000
November Rental: $20,000
December Rental: $25,000

David Tenenbaum  (631) 771-5322
22 Lilla Lane, Springs, Hamptons, NY - 3 Bedrooms  
3 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 21
22 Lilla Lane
$50,000*
Springs
3 BR  |  3 BA
Seasonal Availability*

August - LD Rental: $50,000

Leslie Hillel  (631) 771-5311
David Tenenbaum  (631) 771-5322