North Menantic Road
Shelter Island, NY
$45,000 Rental Price
5 Bedrooms   4.5 Baths

Historic Shelter Island Waterfront Renta

This magnificent Victorian residence c.1860 presides over 2.94-acres of lushly landscaped property on scenic Menantic Creek with a deep water dock. The property boasts original classic details, a wonderful covered porch, rolling lawn down to a most peaceful waterfront, and a heated pool. Inside is a country kitchen, formal...

This magnificent Victorian residence c.1860 presides over 2.94-acres of lushly landscaped property on scenic Menantic Creek with a deep water dock. The property boasts original classic details, a wonderful covered porch, rolling lawn down to a most peaceful waterfront, and a heated pool. Inside is a country kitchen, formal dining room which opens on to the back porch, living room with fireplace, six bedrooms, four and one-half-baths, central air-conditioning, and a separate two-car garage. Available July through Labor Day. Don't miss this opportunity to spend some much needed vacation time in this beautiful waterfront home.

Listing Details

Shelter Island, NY
Type: Seasonal Rental
Price: $45,000
Approx. square footage: 3,000 sf
Last Updated: 5/1/2024
Web ID: 868109

MD - LD Rental: $200,000
June Rental: $15,000
June/July Rental: $55,000
July Rental: $45,000
July / Aug Rental: $100,000
August - LD Rental: $55,000

Info & Amenities

Type: Single Family
Size: 2.94 acres
Bedrooms: 5
Full Bathrooms: 4
Half Bathrooms: 1.0
Fireplaces: 1
Furnished: Yes
Washer and dryer: Yes
Built: 1860
Central Air: Yes
Garage: Yes
Style: Victorian
Pool: Yes

Listing Agent(s)

Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Mary Ellen McGuire
Mary Ellen McGuire
Email Mary Ellen
o: 631-537-4324
c: 516-635-3319

More from this Agent

Miankoma Lane, Amagansett, Hamptons, NY - 6 Bedrooms  
6.5 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 35
Miankoma Lane
$235,000*
Amagansett
6 BR  |  6.5 BA
Seasonal Availability*

MD - LD Rental: $495,000
July / Aug Rental: $425,000
August - LD Rental: $235,000

Mary Ellen McGuire  (631) 537-4324
Timothy R. O'Connor  (631) 771-5321
Lumber Lane, Bridgehampton, Hamptons, NY - 2 Bedrooms  
1 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 12
Lumber Lane
$20,000*
Bridgehampton
2 BR  |  1 BA
Seasonal Availability*

MD - LD Rental: $55,000
June Rental: $15,000
June/July Rental: $35,000
July Rental: $20,000
July / Aug Rental: $45,000
September Rental: $5,500
Year Round: $80,000

Mary Ellen McGuire  (631) 537-4324
Maritza Jimenez  (631) 204-2411
Aelfies Way, Bridgehampton, Hamptons, NY - 5 Bedrooms  
4.5 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 24
Aelfies Way
$50,000*
Bridgehampton
5 BR  |  4.5 BA
Seasonal Availability*

June Rental: $26,000
September Rental: $38,000

Mary Ellen McGuire  (631) 537-4324