67 Garden Street
Village of Sag Harbor, NY
$1,895,000 Price
2 Bedrooms   1.0 Bath

Upcoming Open House

Wednesday, May 14, 2025, 11:00 - 1:00
67 Garden Street

Charming Historic Home-Sag Harbor Villag

Nestled in the Historic District and listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this delightful one-and-a-half-story home is available for the first time in over 50 years. Thoughtfully maintained and full of character, the two-bedroom, one-bath residence offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of history. The...

Nestled in the Historic District and listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this delightful one-and-a-half-story home is available for the first time in over 50 years. Thoughtfully maintained and full of character, the two-bedroom, one-bath residence offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of history. The exterior features classic shingle siding, two-over-two light wooden sash windows, and a cross-gabled roof. An inviting enclosed front porch leads into the warm and welcoming interior. Step inside to a cozy living room and a lovely open kitchen and dining area, complete with a gas fireplace and charming stained glass accents. Both bedrooms and the bath are conveniently located on the main floor, making for easy single-level living. The second floor is open and airy with a vaulted ceiling allowing for a variety of uses, including a home office. The spacious back deck is ideal for lounging or al fresco summer dining with an adjacent outdoor shower. The open backyard enjoys abundant sunlight and privacy provided by mature hedges with room for pool. A versatile 268 sq. ft. outbuilding offers flexible space for a potting shed, extra storage, or future pool house. 1/4 of a mile to American Hotel, Sag Harbor Cinema and a variety of wonderful Sag Harbor shopping and dining options. Off-street parking adds convenience, and the home is slated to connect to municipal sewer in Fall 2025. Listing ID:922305

Calculate your Payments

Asking Price:

Percent Down:

Loan Amount:

Interest Rate:

Loan Term (years):

Estimated Mortgage Payment:

Monthly Real Estate Tax:

Total Monthly Payment:

* All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental, financing or estimated mortgage rates is from sources deemed reliable but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof. For further financing information, please contact a Brown Harris Stevens agent.

Listing Details

New Listing
Village of Sag Harbor, NY
Type: House
Price: $1,895,000
Approx. sqft: 888 sf
Re Tax: $6,021
Date Listed: 5/12/2025
Last Updated: 5/14/2025
Web ID: 922305

Info & Amenities

Type: Single Family
Size: 0.16 acres
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1.0
Kitchen: Eat In
Fireplaces: 1
Washer and dryer: Yes
Built: 1860
Room for Pool: Yes
Style: Historic

Listing Agent(s)

Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Linley Pennebaker Hagen
Linley Pennebaker Hagen
Email Linley Pennebaker
o: 631-725-5583
c: 516-429-1808
Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Kimberly Kakerbeck
Kimberly Kakerbeck
Email Kimberly
o: 631-537-4351
c: 917-374-5985

More from these Agents

Glover Street, Village Of Sag Harbor, Hamptons, NY - 3 Bedrooms  
2 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 11
Glover Street
$23,000*
Village Of Sag Harbor
3 BR  |  2 BA
Seasonal Availability*

Two Week Rental: $23,000

Kimberly Kakerbeck  (631) 537-4351
Linley Pennebaker Hagen  (631) 725-5583
Howard Street, Village Of Sag Harbor, Hamptons, NY - 2 Bedrooms  
1 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 9
Howard Street
$15,000*
Village Of Sag Harbor
2 BR  |  1 BA
Seasonal Availability*

MD - LD Rental: $45,000
June Rental: $10,000
June/July Rental: $20,000
July Rental: $15,000
July / Aug Rental: $35,000
August - LD Rental: $25,000
September Rental: $7,500
October Rental: $5,000
November Rental: $5,000
Short Term Weekly: $20,000

Kimberly Kakerbeck  (631) 537-4351
Brick Kiln Road, Sag Harbor, Hamptons, NY - 4 Bedrooms  
4 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 12
Brick Kiln Road
$70,000*
Sag Harbor
4 BR  |  4 BA
Seasonal Availability*

MD - LD Rental: $175,000
June Rental: $35,000
July Rental: $70,000
July / Aug Rental: $140,000
August - LD Rental: $75,000

Kimberly Kakerbeck  (631) 537-4351