Madison Street
Village of Sag Harbor, NY
$90,000 Rental Price
7 Bedrooms   5.5 Baths

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE COMPOUND ON AN ACRE

This custom-designed, impeccably built home is set on ne of the largest properties in Sag Harbor Village. It is an acre accomodating a 50-foot Gunite Pool, spa, separate air conditioned pool house, outdoor shower, detached garage and legal 3 bedroom guest house. Set on one of the district's...

This custom-designed, impeccably built home is set on ne of the largest properties in Sag Harbor Village. It is an acre accomodating a 50-foot Gunite Pool, spa, separate air conditioned pool house, outdoor shower, detached garage and legal 3 bedroom guest house. Set on one of the district's largest properties in the village, it combines the charm of village living and accessibility to Main Street shopping in a private atmosphere. The design offers a thoughtful open-plan main floor, maximizing space and functionality. This level offers a generously proportioned kitchen, dining area comfortably seating ten, a lovely living room with a wood-burning fireplace, perfect for intimate gatherings. Completing the main floor is a spacious mudroom and a discreet powder room. The large loft-like family room opens through French doors to a generous covered porch with western exposures overlooking the pool, expansive landscaping and sunsets. Relaxation and entertainment, is ideal in this space featuring seating for ten and a gas grill adding to the opportunity to entertain. The second floor, greets you with amazing the primary suite offering a full bath, a walk-in closet, and a west-facing deck, providing a tranquil spot to enjoy the sunset. This level also accommodates three additional bedrooms, a full bath, a convenient laundry room, and a book nook, perfect for quiet moments. The lower level boasts a sprawling 1200-square-foot space, fully furnished and dedicated to recreation with a TV area, ping pong table, pool table, and another full bath. A breezeway connects to a historic guesthouse dating back to the 1800s, offering three additional bedrooms on the upper level, a full bath, and a first level featuring a formal living room, dining area, powder room, pantry, and laundry, a real plus for the tenants who prefer their privacy, yet love their family and friends. Finally, the garage accommodates secure parking for two vehicles and includes a dedicated EV charging station, with ample storage space. This historic residence combines charm with contemporary elegance. It is a unique and exceptional offering in the most sought after village in the Hamptons, Sag Harbor.

Listing Details

Village of Sag Harbor, NY
Type: Seasonal Rental
Price: $90,000
Approx. square footage: 5,050 sf
Last Updated: 6/16/2025
Web ID: 907650

July Rental: $90,000

Info & Amenities

Type: Single Family
Size: 0.92 acres
Bedrooms: 7
Full Bathrooms: 5
Half Bathrooms: 1
Fireplaces: 1
Washer and dryer: Yes
Built: 2004
Central Air: Yes
Style: Traditional

Listing Agent(s)

Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Andrea L. Ackerman
Andrea L. Ackerman
Email Andrea
o: 631-537-4340
c: 516-356-0900
Brown Harris Stevens Real Estate Agent Elizabeth A. Phenis
Elizabeth A. Phenis
Email Elizabeth
o: 631-537-4357
c: 516-241-1188

More from these Agents

22 Huckleberry Lane, East Hampton, Hamptons, NY - 4 Bedrooms  
2.5 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 15
22 Huckleberry Lane
$30,000*
East Hampton
4 BR  |  2.5 BA
Seasonal Availability*

June Rental: $20,000
June/July Rental: $45,000
July Rental: $30,000

Andrea L Ackerman  (631) 537-4340
Elizabeth A Phenis  (631) 537-4357
27 Moses Lane, Village Of Southampton, Hamptons, NY - 4 Bedrooms  
2 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 27
27 Moses Lane
$35,000*
Village Of Southampton
4 BR  |  2 BA
Seasonal Availability*

MD - LD Rental: $90,000
August Rental: $35,000
August - LD Rental: $35,000
Year Round: $120,000

Andrea L Ackerman  (631) 537-4340
Elizabeth A Phenis  (631) 537-4357
57 Big Fresh Pond Road, Southampton, Hamptons, NY - 5 Bedrooms  
4 Bathrooms - Previous PhotoNext Photo1 of 18
57 Big Fresh Pond Road
$110,000*
Southampton
5 BR  |  4 BA
Seasonal Availability*

November Rental: $7,000
December Rental: $7,000
Year Round: $110,000

Andrea L Ackerman  (631) 537-4340
Elizabeth A Phenis  (631) 537-4357